FIDELITY LAND TITLE, LTD was founded by Donald R. Tully in 1949. 309 S. Main Street has been the home for FIDELITY LAND TITLE, LTD. since 1967, when its founder bought the former St. Mary's Episcopal Church in May of that year.

Originally the first building to occupy this address was the Universalists Church which had been built in the mid-1800's. In 1902, St Mary's Episcopal Congregation rebuilt the church as it stands today. The church continued its worship until 1959, when they merged and moved the congregation to Fort Atkinson.

In order to keep up with the ever increasing real estate demands, it became necessary for FIDELITY LAND TITLE, LTD. to expand its operation to facilitate those demands. After many months of planning, 1987 was the year for said expansion of a two-story - 5,000 square foot addition to the existing building. Included in that expansion was the main closing room and atrium overlooking the city fountain; two circular-conference/closing rooms and additional offices.

Their commitment to quality and service is reflected in its logo "BUILT ON FAITH - SUSTAINED BY SERVICE".